Bar Carolina

Average price $95
204 reviews

Free serviceInstant booking

Restaurant menu

Average price $95 Special request

Ratings & Reviews

based on 204 reviews
Only customers who have dined at the restaurant after making a booking on TheFork can leave a review.
Quality of food :8.8/10
Service :8.5/10
Setting :8.5/10
  1. Demmi P.
    Demmi P.
    • 3 reviews

    The restaurant was loud, & crowded but I overall service was excellent and attention to detail. Food was flavoursome Great night out.. thank you

  2. Luca R.
    Luca R.
    • one review

    First time at Bar Carolina. Beautiful experience, loved everything: welcoming staff, amazing food(high quality), super wine list. Will be back

  3. Penny F.
    Penny F.
    • one review

    Delicious food, presentation, quality - we had zucchini flowers with goats cheese, the lamb on a white bean puree that was utterly beautiful. Sides of fresh salad, broccolini and potatoes also delicious. Dessert - creme brulee bluberry divine.

  4. Loke Fong K.
    Loke Fong K.
    • one review

    Excellent customer service. Seafood pasta is fresh, steak cooked perfectly, dessert is tasty especially their signature tiramisu. Strongly recommended!

  5. Clare D.
    Clare D.
    • 2 reviews

    Disappointed in that we were not informed at time of booking nor on arrival that our table was only available until 8pm. Towards the end felt rushed and eventually informed our table was needed for another booking. Our evening came to a rapid end.

  6. Liz G.
    Liz G.
    • one review

    Worst Italian food I have had in a long time , would not recommend this restaurant to anyone. We eat Italian food allot and the offerings here try to be trendy given the location but the quality of cooking and flavours sadly miss the base by a long shot

  7. A A.
    A A.
    • 276 reviews

    sophisticated buzz, fabulous aperitivo and classic italian dishes

  8. A A.
    A A.
    • 278 reviews

    Good food but seemed understaffed - service was lacking.

  9. A A.
    A A.
    • 247 reviews

    Great ambience.

  10. A A.
    A A.
    • 257 reviews

    The worst service I have had in a restaurant ever!!! So arrogant. Pity I used to like the restaurant.

  11. A A.
    A A.
    • 233 reviews

    A little pricey

  12. A A.
    A A.
    • 276 reviews

    The food was nice, however I was not particularly wowed by any specific dish. I will have to come back to sample other dishes on the menu, to give a more thorough review. I ordered the tiramisu for dessert, however the restaurant’s inventive interpretation left me a little disappointed as I was really hoping for a traditional slice. However what I received resembled more of a rum and raisin flavoured mousse, served in what appeared to be a white version of the Death Star from Star Wars. Nothing wrong with the dessert, really, but it would have been nice if the menu reflected more accurately what I would receive. The staff were really friendly and helpful, which was great. The wine list was excellent.

  13. ALBERT  M.
    • 14 reviews

    As been there on many times perfect night nothing else .

  14. A A.
    A A.
    • 257 reviews

    Had a 2:30 booking and received very little attention from waitstaff while they set up for dinner service. Struggled to order drinks and dessert. Felt extremely unwelcome. Such a shame given the food is top notch.

  15. A A.
    A A.
    • 269 reviews

    The food it outstanding - fresh and delicious

  16. A A.
    A A.
    • 253 reviews

    No vegan option despite me specifying vegan when booking. Made a tasteless and expensive vegan pasta which was very expensive. Friends clams were very sandy

  17. A A.
    A A.
    • 290 reviews

    Very good service and food beautifully cooked.

  18. Luke W.
    Luke W.
    • 4 reviews

    Great food - highly recommended!

  19. A A.
    A A.
    • 268 reviews

    The food was amazing. The calamari entree was outstanding. The parpadelle special with braised rabbit was out of this world.

  20. Al Y.
    Al Y.
    • one review

    Loved it, great little nook to drink and dine.

More information

How to get to the restaurant

44 Toorak Road, 3141, South Yarra, Australia

Directions to get there

Melbourne South East, South Yarra

About the restaurant

Located in South Yarra, Bar Carolina is the perfect place to visit on your next date night. Get excited to experience their Italian inspired menu. It’s an experience you won’t forget!




Amex Welcome

Restaurants around Bar Carolina

Tao Dumplings South Yarra

South Yarra

Score:7.4 6 reviews

South Yarra

$40 average price

Score:8.9 25 reviews

South Yarra

$55 average price

Score:8.4 71 reviews

South Yarra

$75 average price

Score:9.4 265 reviews

South Yarra

$35 average price

Score:8.5 70 reviews

South Yarra

$50 average price

Score:7.9 4 reviews

South Yarra

$95 average price

Score:9.1 343 reviews

South Yarra

Score:9.4 4 reviews

South Yarra

$85 average price

Score:9.3 364 reviews

South Yarra

$45 average price

Score:8.1 123 reviews


Free serviceInstant booking