Elsternwick Hotel

Cam V. • 1 review

28 October 2023

7.5/10

Great serving size and good quality food. Downside - when you accidentally come through the pokies room and get told off, not a great start to the evening, considering no sign from car park. 50-50 would go again

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Hi Cam. Glad you enjoyed your meals. Sorry you didn't enjoy the service.

Jon C. • 1 review

11 October 2023

4/10

Roast of the day was soo sad!

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Hi Jon. Please call us on 03 9531 3218 to discuss. Thanks.

David K. • 1 review

1 October 2023

10/10

The staff and vibe at the Elsternwick Hotel were awesome. Service was really quick, and the food was really good too. Overall an awesome experience :)

LikeReport

June E. • 1 review

25 August 2023

10/10

The staff were fantastic and the barramundi fresh and tasty. It was served up promptly. Ambience very pleasant.

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thanks for the feedback June! Look forward to seeing you next time.

Andrew D. • 4 reviews

9 June 2023

9/10

Nice pub, standard pub fare in old building. . Sadly our booked table was given to someone else so there was a bit of jiggling to get us in. We got a park in the street but car park was full. .

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Jiggling is what we do best! Hope the table we gave you was much better than your allocated one. Thanks for the review Andrew. Hope to see you again soon 😊

Val C. • 1 review

30 May 2023

8.5/10

lovely welcoming staff, esp the young man who appeared to be in charge - what charisma!

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Hi Val. Thanks for the kind words. See you next time!

HEATHER E. • 1 review

28 May 2023

7.5/10

The food was good, the service was very good and although they were quite busy nothing took too long. The drinks were good but a tad expensive, all in all a good venue

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Hi Heather. Thanks for the review 😊

EMILIE M. • 2 reviews

17 March 2023

7/10

Came for St.Patrick’s Day because they serve a great Guinness compared to other areas in Bayside. The food specials were pretty average for St.Paddy’s but at least they tried to be a bit Irish. We were 2 families together; comfortable large space for us to all enjoy together. It was a nice night

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Sorry you had an ordinary experience. Hope you give us another go!

Tony H. • 1 review

5 March 2023

10/10

Everything was just perfect. Great staff. Great venue with plenty of atmosphere and you could hear each other speak without being drowned out by loud music... Great food at very good prices..

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thanks for the great review!

ADAM R. • 9 reviews

24 February 2023

10/10

Great food and service

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thanks for the great review!

Hazel T. • 5 reviews

14 January 2023

10/10

Great local pub with great selection of freshly cooked meals. Their steaks are tasty, their roast lamb meal is delicious,. Seafood is fresh and staff are always friendly.

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thanks for the great review!

ADAM R. • 9 reviews

12 January 2023

10/10

Awesome meals and service

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thanks for the great review!

ADAM R. • 9 reviews

31 December 2022

10/10

Awesome meals and service

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thanks for the great review!

ADAM R. • 9 reviews

16 December 2022

10/10

Awesome food and customer service ????

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thanks for the great review!

Denis B. • 2 reviews

1 December 2022

5.5/10

Disappointed with the changes to the menu at Elsternwick hotel. Prefer the old menu. Not inclined to return and will seek alternative venue for the future. Don’t like the need to order a side of vegetables when I just wished to substitute chips for vegetables.

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Sorry you had a poor experience. Hope you give us another go!

Evan W. • 3 reviews

7 October 2022

6.5/10

Much better now you are not forced to order through the website. I know it has advantages in terms of being able to reduce staff, but service is heaps better if you can tailor orders For example. “ Parma with gravy in a jug on the side” “Bourbon and coke in a tall glass with twice the usual amount of Coke on top of a single shot” Happy to keep patronising now whereas we were thinking seriously if going elsewhere

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thank you Evan for your review. We hope to see you again soon.

Tammy D. • 6 reviews

18 September 2022

10/10

Great food, service and cosy pub vibe. Will definitely be back!

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thank you Tammy for your kind review. We hope to see you again soon

GABBY S. • 1 review

7 September 2022

10/10

True pub warmth and hospitality, love the fire as it creates an ambiance that is so missing in other restaurants. An ideal place to catch up with old friends and meet new friends.

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thank you Gabby for your kind review. See you again soon

Cameron G. • 1 review

25 August 2022

7.5/10

We had a catchup at the Elsty - local for most of us - it was good and worked for us - reasonable price and beef cheeks (special) was great - just better vegies would help thanks Cheers

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thank you Cameron, for your feedback. I have passed your notes onto the chef. Hope to see you again soon.

Bradley h. • 1 review

15 August 2022

10/10

Very nice quiet and accommodating for a family. Had a excellent time and really enjoyed the food. Staff were very friendly and welcoming. Definitely recommended for a small celebration like we had, more then enough room for larger groups also. Well done and thank you

LikeReport

Elsternwick Hotel • Owner

Thank you Bradley for your kind review, we hope to see you again soon.