Gemma Simply Italian

Ekaterina S.

15 July 2021 • 1 review

5.5/10

The gnocchi was disappointing, said there was basil but had only one basil leaf. My friend's parpadelli pasta with eggplant looked better though. We waited a whole hour for our foRead more

Corey H.

13 July 2021 • 1 review

10/10

The restaurant has a great ambience, great menu, service and amazing tasting food. The service from our water was good and he even let us know about the city of Melbourne promotion.

Duncan C.

7 July 2021 • 2 reviews

9/10

We love Gemma. The food is always great. And who can turn down a $15 pizza special on Wednesday?

Jayne T.

26 June 2021 • 1 review

8/10

The staff were great but as soon as it got busy we had to wait a long time. The meals did not come out together so we waited until all of our table was served before starting to eRead more

Liane B.

18 June 2021 • 1 review

9/10

Great ambience. Delicious dinner. Dessert okay. Warm, cosy atmosphere. Happy to go back again. Good for night out with friends or family. Happy to recommend.

Anthony P.

13 June 2021 • 1 review

10/10

We decided to visit this lovely Italian restaurant in Carlton. The decor and atmosphere was a pleasing sight and the service was impeccable. The food was delicious and the wait timRead more

Carly S.

24 May 2021 • 1 review

10/10

The food, atmosphere and staff were all excellent, we all loved it! We are newly local to the area and are sure to become regulars. We especially loved the authentic feel.

Steven M.

22 May 2021 • 1 review

10/10

Gemma Simply Italian is amazing. Food. Ambience. Staff. All 5 stars. The minute you walk in you get this warm rush of air and the vibe is amazing. Definitely a must go, we had the Read more

Catherine K.

20 May 2021 • 1 review

10/10

Gemma Simply Italian was such a treat! This cozy restaurant has the best gnocchi in Carlton! The staff were so welcoming and helpful. The food was delicious and delivered quickly.

Brett D.

16 May 2021 • 1 review

10/10

Being a Pizza and Gnocchi specialist, we expected it to be good - the gnocchi was light, fluffy in a stunning sauce and the pizza topped tastefully, cooked to perfection. ExcellentRead more

Olivia L.

15 May 2021 • 1 review

9/10

The food was great, the pizza was beautifully thin and crispy, just how we like them. We loved the olives and the Bruchetta was a great start to the meal. I always stay away from Read more

R M.

14 May 2021 • 1 review

10/10

The service was friendly and efficient and the food was fantastic. My table shared a pizza, parpadelle, gnocchi and caprese salad. I plan to go back and work my way through the pizRead more

Jon C.

9 May 2021 • 1 review

4.5/10

Gemma’s has always been my favourite restaurant but the owner has changed and the food is now very very disappointing! The menu is the same but the Quattro formaggio gnocchi didn’tRead more

Gemma Simply Italian (Owner)

Sorry to hear this Jon. The night you visited us was very busy and perhaps the kitchen made a mistake with your order in the rush. We are consistent with the ingredients we use anRead more

Mandy T.

7 May 2021 • 4 reviews

10/10

This bustling restaurant serves delicious Italian fare and never fails to please. The staff are friendly and welcoming. Be sure to book, to make sure you don't miss out!

Aneesha J

4 April 2021 • 1 review

9.5/10

Brilliant little restaurant with great tasting food and great service. People were friendly. Would highly recommend and will definitely be coming back.

Robyn C.

3 April 2021 • 1 review

8.5/10

Great spot with friendly service. Our family loved it

Javier U.

28 March 2021 • 1 review

9.5/10

Good prices. Small, nice and friendly place. I recommend it 100 %. Good food and wine, with truly italian food, and less expensive that other italian restaurants in Melbourne.

Lucy B.

20 February 2021 • 1 review

8/10

This restaurant was a great last minute find. The staff were friendly, service good and reasonably quick however we went during a quiet period. Pizzas were great. Pastas tasted deRead more

Mandy T.

19 February 2021 • 4 reviews

10/10

Gemma ticked all the boxes. The staff were very warm and welcoming, and the service was great. The food here is excellent, and arrived in good time. We had the calamari (delicious!Read more

Chung C.

3 February 2021 • 1 review

10/10

My go to Italian restaurant. Owners and waitresses are exceptional, attentive and friendly. Their gnocci's and fire oven pizzas are simply devine. Highly recommended.