739 Verified Diner Reviews

Take it from the experts - we gather information from foodie experts to provide you with valuable inside knowledge and detailed descriptions on restaurants from around the country.

Total Score

7.3
739 reviews
Recommended
(7.2)
Food
(7.3)
Service
(7.1)
Value for money
(7.8)
Atmosphere
(7.5)

dined on Sat, 17 Aug 2019

(5)
Tried the bottomless brunch. $50 pp if you book it online. Loads of drunk bucks & hens groups. You get about 5 breakfast style options to choose from. All the drinks are pre-made (Mimosas/Sangria/Froze) and felt a little watered down and light on for the money compared to Bang Bang Elsternwick Bottomless Brunch they include full size cocktails and 7 piece tapas. The music was the worst - 1990s MMM playlist!
Hi Sarah, thank you for taking the time to review us, and thank you for providing your valuable feedback. We're sorry to hear that your experience with us was less than ideal, and apologise for the lack of atmosphere. Unfortunately our Spotify was down for the day and automatic playlist, which has since been switched off, played in its place. As far as our drinks being watered down, we're unsure of what you mean as our brunch offer doesn't really give us any room for this to happen. We'd like to hear more about your experience and it would be great if you could contact us at admin@newmarketstkilda.com.au to get a little bit more detail on you visit. Hope to hear from you soon. Kind Regards The ManagementTeam
Admin, Newmarket Hotel responded on Sun, 25 Aug 2019
Ellen

dined on Mon, 12 Aug 2019

(10)
Steak night on Monday is amazing as always.
Ellen

dined on Mon, 29 Apr 2019

(10)
Delicious steaks as always!
Hi Ellen, thanks for sharing your positive experience with us! We're so pleased to hear that our steak impressed you so much! We here at Newmarket Hotel believe there is no substitute for fresh, quality ingredients. We hope to see you in again soon, and that you'll give one of our other classic menu items a go! Sincerely, The Management Team.
Admin, Newmarket Hotel responded on Sun, 7 Jul 2019

dined on Sat, 14 Sep 2019

(4)
Not impressed Waited 20 min for last person to get their wine. Had to go up and ask for it. Poke bowl was terrible.
Jo

dined on Mon, 2 Sep 2019

(10)
All 3 steaks cooked to perfection. G-R-E-A-T service! Love the Beerenberg tomato sauce. Back soon.

dined on Wed, 28 Aug 2019

(8)
Great hotel for food and drinks

dined on Tue, 27 Aug 2019

(9)
More vegetarian options! Otherwise the puppy parma night was great fun, great staff, patrons were all lovely to one another.

dined on Sun, 18 Aug 2019

(1)
We had a booking for six people prior to a function at the Fyrefly in the basement of the Newmarket Hotel. From the time we arrived we had to wIt to be seated when the restaurant was less than half full. We ordered mulled wine, only for the waitress to return a while later to say it was not of the highest quality and not being served. We then ordered dinner, a selection of entree’s and main courses. 15 minutes later the waiter returned to advise there was no brisket for the Sliders and could we change our orders. 10 minutes later the waiter returned again to advise there was no Gyozo and could we choose another dish. Then eventually 2 dishes were served and we waited some more then another dish was served, but alas it wasn’t what was ordered. Then half an hour later the other dishes arrived. All the while the waitress was very apologetic with the excuse one of the chefs called in sick so they were understaffed in the kitchen! Still waiting for a pizza that was ordered an hour earlier eventually it arrived but by then it was too late to salvage any positive feeling about this dining experience. Unfortunately I could not recommend this restaurant and unsure why this experience was so poor on all aspects of of service and food.
Hi, thank you for providing us with your valuable feedback, without which we cannot improve. We'd like to apologise for your experience, and would like to ask if you could please contact us directly at admin@newmarketstkilda.com.au to discuss the matter further. Sincerely, The Management Team.
Admin, Newmarket Hotel responded on Wed, 21 Aug 2019

dined on Sat, 17 Aug 2019

(6)
Like most bars on Melbourne, beverages overpriced.
Thank you for taking the time to write a review. We appreciate your comments and regret to hear you were disappointed with the value of our beverage selection. We aim to provide all our customers with a high quality experience and we hope to see you again in the near future. Sincerely, The Management Team.
Admin, Newmarket Hotel responded on Sun, 25 Aug 2019

dined on Fri, 16 Aug 2019

(10)
Great food but we ordered small plates to share which all came out at once. We should have asked for them to be staggered
Hi, thank you for taking the time to share your experience at Newmarket Hotel with us. We're so pleased you enjoyed our various shared entrée options. We have passed your feedback onto the team in regards to the staggering of dishes so that this can be presented as an option in the future to enhance our diners experience. We hope to see you in again soon! Sincerely, The Management Team.
Admin, Newmarket Hotel responded on Sun, 25 Aug 2019
page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10

Specials

Martini Brunch $54pp

The best way to get your caffeine fix is a bottomless martini brunch.. Book a delicious brunch with 2 hours of bottomless espresso martinis, mimosas, bellinis and selected beer & wines for $54pp! To view the full menu please visit the "Brunch" section of our website. Management reserves the right to refuse service. Terms and Conditions - Confirmation of your booking is required 48 hours prior to your booking time, don’t worry we will call to confirm! - We take the credit card as a security only. Nothing will be charged to your card. Your bill is to be paid in full at the arrival for your reservation, the package will begin after that. - If you choose to cancel your reservation less than 48 hours before your booking time or fail to show up, there may incur a charge of 50% of the set menu price charged to the card provided at time of booking. - Tables will be allocated by the venue. - When notified of food allergies & intolerances we will take all due care to ensure meals or beverages served are free from notified products. However, we cannot guarantee that the meals or beverages will be free from trace elements. Please ensure that you notify us of any requirements 48 hours or more prior to booking.
When
15 Feb 2018 - 31 Jan 2021
Sat 11:30 AM - 11:30 AM
When
15 Feb 2018 - 31 Jan 2021
Sat 2:00 PM - 2:00 PM
When
15 Feb 2018 - 31 Jan 2021
Sun 12:00 PM - 12:00 PM
Book special
Special selected! Remove

Cocktail Masterclass $65pp

Learn how to shake and stir from the experts. It’s a great way to start your night, or even just to mix it up with some of your friends or work colleagues. The class costs $65pp, which includes 3 cocktails and charcuterie to share. Terms and Conditions ● Confirmation of your booking is required 48 hours prior to your booking time, don’t worry we will call to confirm! ● We accept all major credit cards or cash. ● We take credit card details as security only. The bill is to be paid in full on arrival. If you choose to cancel the whole reservation within 48 hours of the booking, or if your group numbers drop by more than 3 in the same period of time, 50% of the selected package will be charged to the card provided. ● All non-attendees on the day may incur a fee on the package. ● When notified of food allergies & intolerances we will take all due care to ensure meals or beverages served are free from notified products. However, we cannot guarantee that the meals or beverages will be free from trace elements. Please ensure that you notify us of any requirements 48 hours or more prior to booking.
Min. people
4
Max. people
12
When
25 Sep 2018 - 31 Dec 2020
Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Fri 12:00 AM - 11:59 PM
When
25 Sep 2018 - 31 Dec 2020
Sun, Sat 3:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Book special
Special selected! Remove

Martini Brunch $49pp (Pre-paid)

Pay in advance and receive $5 off per person (one transaction only). The best way to get your caffeine fix is a bottomless martini brunch.. Book a delicious brunch with 2 hours of bottomless espresso martinis, mimosas, bellinis and selected beer & wines for $49pp! To view the full menu please visit the "Brunch" section of our website. Management reserves the right to refuse service. Terms and Conditions - Confirmation of your booking is required 48 hours prior to your booking time, don’t worry we will call to confirm! -Full payment is required at the time of your booking. -If you choose to cancel the whole booking we will require 72 hours notice of the booking date. Cancellations after this period will be charged at full price.
When
15 Feb 2018 - 31 Jan 2021
Sat 11:30 AM - 11:30 AM
When
15 Feb 2018 - 31 Jan 2021
Sun 12:00 PM - 12:00 PM
When
15 Feb 2018 - 31 Jan 2021
Sat 2:00 PM - 2:00 PM
Book special
Special selected! Remove

Trivia @ 7:30

Every Monday from 7:30pm, round up your brains trust and join us for trivia. There’s a $100 Newmarket voucher up for grabs, plus other great prizes on the night. Plus, we’ve got 50% off steaks all night.
When
10 May 2019 - 30 Apr 2022
Mon 6:30 PM - 7:30 PM
Book special
Special selected! Remove

Puppy Parma Tuesdays

We’re extending our weekly parma special to man’s best friend. The Puppy Parma consists of a mini chicken schnitzel, shaved ham and is topped with bocconcini and greens. Of course, no parma is complete without a side of “chips” (duck & turmeric dog treats) and “salad” (chicken, rice & vegetable kibble). This canine delicacy is available every Tuesday for just $5. Their human companions can still enjoy our regular parma for just $15 every Tuesday. Available in the Courtyard.
When
12 Jul 2019 - 31 Aug 2022
Tue 4:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Book special
Special selected! Remove

Melbourne Cup High Tea Brunch $60pp

Join us for a two-hour drinks package with a high tea lunch. Drinks include: English Fizz, Pimms, Peach Tea Cocktail, Mimosas and House Lager. TERMS AND CONDITIONS ● Confirmation of your booking is required 48 hours prior to your booking time, don’t worry we will call to confirm! ● We accept all major credit cards or cash. ● We take credit card details as security only. The bill is to be paid in full at the end of your stay with us. If you choose to cancel the whole reservation within 48 hours of the booking, or if your group numbers drop by more than 3 in the same period of time, 50% of the menu selected will be charged to the card provided. ● All non-attendees on the day may incur a fee on the banquet menu. ● When notified of food allergies & intolerances we will take all due care to ensure meals or beverages served are free from notified products. However, we cannot guarantee that the meals or beverages will be free from trace elements. Please ensure that you notify us of any requirements 48 hours or more prior to booking.
When
05 Nov 2019
Tue 12:00 PM - 12:00 PM
Book special
Special selected! Remove

Christmas Lunch $95pp

Join us this Christmas for a festive shared style lunch! $95 per adult for 3 courses, and $25 per child for 2 courses. TERMS AND CONDITIONS - A valid credit card is required at the time of your booking. Full payment for your reservations will be charged to the card provided on December 11th 2019. - Final numbers are to be confirmed before December 11th 2019. - Please ensure you inform us on the amount of children attending in your party otherwise your booking will be charge the full adult fee. - We require all dietary requirements 7 days prior for catering purposes. When notified of food allergies & intolerances we will take all due care to ensure meals or beverages served are free from notified products. However, we cannot guarantee that the meals or beverages will be free from trace elements. Please ensure that you notify us of any requirements. - Tables will be allocated and decided by the venue. - Any cancellations made prior to December 11th 2019 may incur a fee of 50% of the set menu price to the card provided. - If you choose to cancel the whole reservation or if numbers drop we require 7 days’ notice of the booking date. Any cancellations or drop in numbers after this period will be charged at full price.
When
25 Dec 2019
Wed 2:30 PM - 2:30 PM
When
25 Dec 2019
Wed 11:30 AM - 11:30 AM
When
25 Dec 2019
Wed 1:00 PM - 1:00 PM
Book special
Special selected! Remove

About Newmarket Hotel

Something for Everyone Located in the heart of St Kilda, the Newmarket Hotel offers an urban and relaxing atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating areas. Take your pick and sit indoors for a more intimate experience or opt for a more laid-back experience outdoors with Newmarket’s beer garden. With endless options, Newmarket Hotel is fit for any laid-back hangout with friends or family. Serving traditional pub fair like burgers, parmas, and ribs with a touch of modern taste, there’s definitely something for everyone. Make sure to grab a drink as the bar houses a wide range of beer taps, with an extended selection of boutiques and varietals. Feeling something different? Newmarket also offers a range of exotic cocktails sure to tingle your tastebuds. So make sure to head down to Newmarket – because there’s something for everyone! Best Dish: Pork Rillettes

Newmarket Hotel Address

Google Map